You open your inbox to find 40% off a brand you like, another 40% off one you don’t remember following, and 50% off something you bought yesterday (of course). Along with the colder weather, that’s November for you.
For a few weeks, sometimes a whole month, companies that sell different things to different people seem to have agreed on what to say. The photos and products change, obviously, but the message is exactly the same: buy now, because it’ll cost more later.
It works. We’ve all gone for it. If you’ve been thinking about buying something for a while, seeing it on sale might be all you need to make up your mind. The problem for the brand starts when that’s the only reason to choose it, because someone else can always knock a little more off the price.
That’s when brands become interchangeable. Customers don’t really care where they buy because, from what they’ve seen, the options are pretty much the same.
Maybe we’re making it too easy to compare on price
Say we’re looking for a chair to work from home. We open about 32 tabs and start comparing. Every chair is ergonomic, comfortable, and designed with us in mind, though none of them seems to know how tall our desk is.
One costs €170 and another costs €125. If we can’t see what accounts for the difference, it’s reasonable to go with the cheaper one.
The first chair might have replaceable parts so you can repair it a few years down the road. It might also let you adjust the seat depth, which matters if you can never quite get comfortable. But if all of that is buried under a huge BLACK WEEK headline, we’re hiding information that could change someone’s mind.
This happens outside of Black Friday, too, but it’s more obvious in November. When everyone has a deal, saying our product is high quality only gets us so far. We also need to explain why this chair costs €45 more.
Maybe the post could give a little less space to the size of the discount and a little more to what makes the chair worth paying for.
Customers catch on fast
You buy a pair of sneakers, and a week later they’re on sale on the same site. It’s annoying. You also remember it the next time you see something you like from that brand, and you decide to wait. After all, they’ll probably send another promo code or run another sale.
When promotions come around often enough, paying full price starts to feel like a bad deal. The brand still sets the price, but the customer has already decided how much they’re willing to pay. And they know they’ll get that price sooner or later.
That’s why it matters what you put on sale and how often. There’s a reason to mark down an older collection. But if new products go on sale shortly after they launch, it’s hard to see why anyone would buy them as soon as they come out. We might be selling a lot during the promotion because we’ve given people little reason to buy the rest of the time.
It also matters who we’re trying to reach. Someone who already buys from us every month might order early to get the discount and then buy less afterward. That’s fine, but it tells a different story from someone who’s been comparing options for a while and finally decides to give us a try. Lumping those sales together in the same report can make the campaign look more effective than it was.
Before running the same discount because “it worked last year,” it’s worth looking at what happened afterward. Those customers might have bought from us in December anyway. This time, they bought in November and paid less.
How you sell it makes a difference
If you want to start getting around by bike and have no idea what to buy, finding 20 models on sale doesn’t make things much easier. You still don’t know which one you need, and now you have until Sunday to decide.
At a bike shop, you expect someone to ask what kind of riding you’ll be doing and explain whether the model you’re looking at is worth the extra money or whether the basic one will do just fine. Getting that advice is a good reason to buy there.
The promotion can work the same way. Including a tune-up after the first few months of riding makes sense for someone who’s just getting started and doesn’t know when to have the brakes checked. It takes care of one thing they were worried about and gives them a reason to come back after the Black Friday signs are gone.
It’s also a chance to show the expertise the shop talks about on its website. Customers get to see that the staff can give them good advice and that they can count on them after they’ve paid.
Putting together an offer like that means listening to what people ask before they buy and what problems they come back with afterward. Taking a percentage off everything is less work, of course, but it makes it that much easier for the only difference between you and the shop next door to be who cut prices the most.
Don’t let Black Friday undo what you’ve built all year
Then there’s the campaign itself. A brand spends months trying to become recognizable, and come November, it changes its voice, its typeface, and even its personality.
It makes sense to use visual cues that tell people there’s a sale. Nobody should have to spend five minutes decoding a post to find out there’s a discount, but you don’t have to look like a different company to announce it.
If a brand usually does a good job of explaining its products, it can keep doing that. If it has a distinctive way of photographing them, that’s worth keeping, too. Those details help people remember where they saw something that caught their eye when they go looking for it again a few hours later.
A lot of purchases happen that way. We see something, set it aside, and come back when we have a chance. If all we remember is a percentage on a black background, good luck finding the brand again.
Black Friday can be a good chance to get someone to buy from us for the first time. What happens after that has a lot to do with whether they buy from us again. If they come back because they got good advice or because the sneakers turned out to be great, they have a reason to choose us even when another brand is on sale. If they only come back when we send them a code, next year we’ll be right back to watching how much the competition is taking off.






